Published on 03.10.17 in Vol 6, No 10 (2017): October
Combined Dietary Nitrate and Exercise Intervention in Peripheral Artery Disease: Protocol Rationale and Design
Background: Peripheral artery disease (PAD) is caused by atherosclerotic occlusions in the legs. It affects approximately 8-12 million people in the United States alone, one-third of whom suffer from intermittent claudication (IC), defined as ischemic leg pain that occurs with walking and improves with rest. Patients with IC suffer a markedly impaired quality of life and a high perception of disability. Improving pain-free walking time is a primary goal of rehabilitation in this population.
Objective: The nitric oxide (NO)-PAD trial is designed to compare the effects that 12 weeks of supervised exercise training, in combination with a high inorganic nitrate-content (beetroot [BR] juice) beverage or placebo (PL) beverage, has on clinical outcomes of exercise and functional capacity in two groups of PAD+IC patients: exercise training plus beetroot (EX+BR) and exercise training plus placebo (EX+PL). The primary aims of this randomized controlled, double-blind pilot study are to determine group differences following 12 weeks of EX+BR versus EX+PL in the changes for (1) exercise capacity: pain-free walking time (claudication onset time, COT), peak walk time (PWT), and maximal exercise capacity (peak oxygen uptake, VO2peak) during a maximal-graded cardiopulmonary exercise test (max CPX) and (2) functional capacity: 6-minute walk (6MW) distance. The secondary aims will provide mechanistic insights into the exercise outcome measures and will include (1) gastrocnemius muscle oxygenation during exercise via near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS); (2) gastrocnemius muscle angiogenesis: capillaries per unit area and per muscle fiber, and relative fraction of type I, IIa, IIb, and IId/x fibers; and (3) vascular health/function via brachial artery flow-mediated dilation, lower-limb blood flow via plethysmography, and pulse wave velocity and reflection.
Methods: A total of 30 subjects between 40 and 80 years of age with PAD who are limited by IC will undergo exercise training 3 days per week for 12 weeks (ie, 36 sessions). They will be randomized to either the EX+BR or EX+PL group where participants will consume a beverage high in inorganic nitrate (4.2 mmol) or a low-nitrate placebo, respectively, 3 hours prior to each training session.
Results: Data collection from this study has been completed and is in the process of analysis and write-up. While the study is too underpowered—EX+BR, n=11; EX+PL, n=13—to determine between-group differences in the primary outcomes of COT, PWT, and 6MW, preliminary observations are promising with Cohen d effect sizes of medium to large.
Conclusions: Exercise training is currently the most effective therapy to increase functional capacity in PAD+IC. If the addition of inorganic nitrate to an exercise regimen elicits greater benefits, it may redefine the current standard of care for PAD+IC.
Trial Registration: ClinicalTrials.gov NCT01684930; https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT01684930 (Archived by WebCite at http://www.webcitation.org/6raXFyEcP)
JMIR Res Protoc 2017;6(10):e139
Crowdfunding campaign to support this specific research
We help JMIR researchers to raise funds to pursue their research and development aimed at tackling important health and technology challenges. If you would like to show your support for this author, please donate using the button below. The funds raised will directly benefit the corresponding author of this article (minus 8% admin fees). Your donations will help this author to continue publishing open access papers in JMIR journals. Donations of over $100 may also be acknowledged in future publications.
Suggested contribution levels: $20/$50/$100
Peripheral artery disease (PAD) is caused by stenosis of the arteries in the lower limbs, leading to a reduction in blood flow to the legs . It affects approximately 8-12 million people within the United States alone, one-third of whom suffer from intermittent claudication (IC), defined as ischemic leg pain that occurs with walking and improves with rest [ ]. Patients with IC suffer a markedly impaired quality of life and a high perception of disability [ ]. Consequently, improving pain-free walking time is an important clinical goal for these patients [ ].
Thus far, interventions aimed at improving clinical outcomes in patients with PAD have been either surgical, pharmacological, or exercise based, with supervised exercise training identified as the current best intervention for improving functional outcomes such as peak walking time and pain-free walking time [- ]. Exercise training has proven efficacy in improving vascular health and function for atherosclerosis-associated comorbidities such as obesity, hypertension, dyslipidemia, and type 2 diabetes mellitus [ - ]. Patients with PAD have marked impairments in the oxygen delivery and uptake pathway due to deficiencies in both vascular function—increased arterial stiffness, endothelial dysfunction, and decreased peripheral blood flow—and skeletal muscle composition and architecture—capillary density rarefaction, mitochondrial dysfunction, and a loss of oxidative (ie, slow-twitch) fibers [ - ]. As they result in a more glycolytic phenotype leading to earlier onset of fatigue and exhaustion, the skeletal muscle abnormalities have a detrimental effect on the delivery, uptake, and utilization of oxygen. While supervised exercise training can improve both the skeletal abnormalities [ ] and vascular function [ ] in these patients, improving the patient’s ability to acutely tolerate an exercise bout could lead to even greater efficacy in the exercise training intervention by allowing them to exercise at a greater intensity at each session. Thus, to identify the next best treatment for patients with PAD, there is a continued need to advance our current understanding of both the disease and optimal interventional therapies.
Dysfunction of the vascular endothelium is a hallmark of cardiovascular diseases, including PAD . A key facet of this dysfunction is abnormal vessel reactivity, which is mediated in part by a reduction in nitric oxide (NO) production [ ]. NO is diatomic free radical that plays an important role in modulating vascular tone and regulating blood flow. In healthy individuals, NO is produced endogenously by endothelial nitric oxide synthase in response to elevated shear stress at the arterial wall. Patients with cardiovascular disease, in particular those with PAD, lack the ability to endogenously increase vascular NO bioavailability, leading to significant dysfunctions within the vasculature.
Plasma nitrite (NO2-), while once considered to be a biologically inert marker of NO, has recently been identified as an alternative NO source that can be reduced to NO under low oxygen conditions, such as hypoxia or ischemia . One established noninvasive mechanism for increasing plasma NO2- is via oral consumption of inorganic nitrate (NO3-). Inorganic NO3- is found in relatively high concentrations in green leafy vegetables and beetroot. When swallowed, inorganic NO3- is rapidly absorbed in the small intestine and while a majority is excreted by the kidneys, up to 25% is retained and becomes concentrated in the salivary glands. When the saliva is secreted, commensal oral bacteria on the dorsal surface of the tongue reduce the NO3- to NO2-, which is then swallowed and absorbed back into the circulation. NO2- concentration peaks approximately 2.5-4 hours after inorganic NO3- consumption [ , ]. The circulating NO2- is further reduced to NO in hypoxic conditions; the NO3- -NO2--NO reduction pathway increases peripheral blood flow during exercise and leads to improvements in exercise tolerance.
NO3- supplementation has shown mixed effects on exercise performance [- ]. In healthy and athletic populations, NO3- supplementation has decreased the oxygen cost of exercise [ , ], increased time to exhaustion [ ], and improved time trial performance [ ]. However, studies utilizing similar participant demographics have reported no effect of NO3- supplementation on power output [ ], time trial time [ ], or submaximal exercise efficiency [ ]. One proposed explanation for these mixed findings is the discovery that an individual’s level of aerobic fitness could impact the effectiveness of nitrate supplementation, with one study demonstrating reductions in the oxygen cost of exercise and improvements in time trial performance only in participants with a low-moderate level of aerobic fitness [ ]. While this research into responders and nonresponders to nitrate supplementation is still in the early stages, this particular finding perhaps lends more support for nitrate supplementation’s potential efficacy in clinical populations with low aerobic capacity. Indeed, in clinical populations, most of the results have been positive: improvements in submaximal endurance, muscle contractile function, and exercise capacity in heart failure [ - ], as well as submaximal exercise endurance in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease [ ]. Only a few studies showed no effect [ ]. In patients with PAD, following a single acute dose of a high-nitrate-containing beetroot (BR) juice (18 mmol), which led to a five-fold increase in plasma nitrite in comparison to placebo (PL) [ ], we have previously shown an 18% and 17% increase in treadmill walking claudication onset time (COT) and peak walk time (PWT), respectively. While initial results show promise, most of the studies have utilized acute dosing strategies and have been limited in both sample size and demographic diversity.
While exercise training is the current best intervention for patients with PAD, by allowing the patients to acutely train at higher intensities—due to improvements in oxygen delivery/uptake—resulting in a greater cumulative effect than exercise alone, the acute benefits of nitrate supplementation on exercise tolerance suggest a potential opportunity to further enhance the effects of exercise training .
The hypothesis of this study is that subjects with peripheral artery disease with intermittent claudication (PAD+IC) who undertake regular consumption of a high-inorganic nitrate (4.2 mmol) supplement in conjunction with 12 weeks of supervised exercise training (exercise training plus beetroot juice [EX+BR]) will experience a greater clinical benefit in pain-free walking time (COT, 6-minute walk [6MW]) and PWT than those undertaking exercise and a placebo beverage (exercise training plus placebo juice [EX+PL]) alone. Specifically, the primary aim of this study is to determine group differences (EX+BR vs EX+PL) in the changes in the following:
- Exercise capacity: pain-free walking time (COT), PWT, and maximal exercise capacity/peak oxygen uptake (VO2peak) during a maximal-graded cardiopulmonary exercise test (max CPX).
- Functional capacity: 6MW distance.
Secondary aims designed to provide mechanistic insight into the exercise outcomes include the following:
- Gastrocnemius tissue oxygenation during max CPX testing via near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS).
- Gastrocnemius muscle angiogenesis: capillaries per unit area and per muscle fiber, and relative fraction of type I, IIa, IIb, and IId/x fibers.
- Vascular health/function via brachial artery flow-mediated dilation, lower-limb blood flow via plethysmography, and pulse wave velocity (PWV) and reflection.
The NO-PAD trial is a pilot, randomized, double-blind, per-protocol design with four different assessment time points (see). This study is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT01785524).
The first round of assessment will act as a baseline with no exercise intervention or supplementation. Following this, all participants will be randomized to groups consuming either a 70 mL (4.2 mmol nitrate) beetroot juice (Beet It, James White Drinks Ltd, Ipswich, UK) or an identical nitrate-depleted placebo. Participants will then repeat the baseline assessments, except for the muscle biopsy, but will consume their assigned beverage 3 hours prior to each visit.
Participants will continue consuming their beverage 3 hours prior to each of their 36 exercise training sessions. Periodically, subjects will be selected for unannounced blood draws at training visits to check plasma nitrate and nitrite concentrations. Post-exercise training, participants will complete the same assessments as the baseline visit while still acutely consuming their beverage before visits. Both groups will then stop consuming the beverage for at least 1 week prior to the final visit. The half-life of nitrate is 5-8 hours and as the supplementation protocol is three acute doses per week, a 1-week washout period should be sufficient to minimize any possible residual effect of the nitrate . To maximize internal validity, study personnel, time of day, equipment, and order of testing will be consistent for each of the assessment time points.
Recruitment Strategies and Eligibility
We aim to recruit a total of 30 participants—equal numbers of men and women—between the ages of 40 and 80 years with diagnosed PAD from the clinics and community at Duke University Medical Center. We anticipate a dropout rate of approximately 15%-20% and, therefore, 24 patients out of the 30 (EX+BR, n=12; EX+PL, n=12) are expected to complete the study. This study will have continuous rolling enrollment until the recruitment goals are met. Subjects will be recruited primarily through collaboration with Duke University Medical Center cardiovascular physicians and vascular surgeons. Clinic medical records will be reviewed to prescreen patients for inclusion and exclusion criteria (see).
Records of those criteria will be noted and the appropriate medical doctor will introduce the study to the patient. Patients who consent to being contacted by the research team will undergo a telephone screening questionnaire to determine if the study eligibility criteria are met. Eligible and interested patients will then attend an orientation visit and a consent meeting. During this initial visit, the study details will be explained verbally and the individuals will have the opportunity to read over the approved informed consent document and ask any questions they may have about the trial. The patients can then choose to sign the informed consent form or decline participation. Following the consent visit, enrolled subjects will return on a separate day to undergo a physical examination and a review of their medical history and medications by the study physician. Participants will then be scheduled for their baseline assessment visits. Details of the testing occurring at each time point is outlined inand is described in detail in the Testing Methodology section.
Following initial screening and baseline testing, subjects will be randomized to consume either a high-nitrate-containing beetroot beverage or a low-nitrate placebo throughout the duration of the exercise training. Randomization should ensure the groups are initially equal within either the EX+BR or EX+PL intervention. Both groups will be instructed to consume one 70 mL bottle of beetroot juice (containing 4.2 mmol inorganic nitrate) 2.5-3 hours prior to every testing visit and training session between time point 2 and time point 3. The beetroot juice bottles will be identical in appearance and taste. The bottles will be color coded by a third party to ensure that the research staff remain blinded while providing the correct supplement to each participant.
Scheduled but unannounced blood draws will be performed throughout the study to confirm participants are conforming to their appropriate beverage allocations.
Overall Program and Attendance Requirements
All subjects will attend supervised exercise training sessions three times per week for a total of 12 weeks at the Duke Health and Fitness Center at the Duke University Medical Center for Living. Each session is structured to last approximately 45-60 minutes, including taking vital signs—heart rate and blood pressure (BP)—before and after the training session. To meet minimum exercise session attendance requirements, participants will need to complete 34 of the 36 exercise training sessions and should not miss more than 1 week of training (ie, 3 sessions) consecutively. Additional sessions will be added if necessary to ensure that an adequate exercise stimulus is given to each subject so that any decreases in fitness or function during unintended breaks are mitigated. The study will be analyzed under per-protocol criteria. Subjects who withdraw from the study prior to completion will be excluded from the final analysis. However, attrition rates will be reported and documented.
Participants will not be excluded due to current exercise habits, but all participants will be instructed to maintain their normal activity levels throughout the exercise intervention.
The exercise session will consist of approximately 5 minutes of warm-up, 30 minutes of accumulated exercise (not including rest periods), and cooldown (if necessary). The walking treadmill exercise prescription is individualized to each participant’s exercise capacity during baseline testing and their rate of progression. The protocol requires participants to accumulate a total of 30 minutes of walking with claudication pain. Neither rest time nor time spent exercising before pain onset will count toward the 30-minute goal. The patient will be encouraged to continue walking as far as they can, but will self-select when they require a rest break. Exercise and rest periods are repeated during each session until the minimum total of 30 minutes of walking time is reached each session. When a patient can walk 8-10 minutes at the initial workload, the grade will be increased by 0.5%, or the speed increased by 0.1 mph as tolerated, to ensure workload progression.
Subjects will be supervised by a trained exercise physiologist and will have continuous telemetry heart rate monitoring using the Polar heart rate monitor (Polar Electro). Fatigue will be assessed through rating of perceived exertion via the Borg 6-20 scale; blood pressure will be checked both before and after exercise as well as periodically during each exercise.
Each exercise training session will be documented with preexercise and postexercise vital signs, time of day beverage was consumed, total exercise time, and workload (ie, treadmill speed and grade) recorded. Body weight and dietary intake will be assessed on a weekly basis. All research team members working with the subjects will be blinded to the treatment intervention and every attempt will be made keep encouragement and workload adjustment standardized between subjects.
The subjects and research staff conducting the testing will be unaware of group assignments. The primary investigator will know to which treatment group the subjects are randomized, since changes in plasma nitrate and nitrite will be used to determine beverage volumes and tolerance. Because of the potential for bias, however, the primary investigator will not be directly involved in collecting or analyzing any of the exercise performance or training data.
For all testing visits, participants will be advised to avoid exercise and consuming alcohol for 24 hours prior to the examination day. They will also be asked to avoid tobacco and caffeine for 3 hours prior to any testing or exercise visit.
Maximal Cardiopulmonary Exercise Test
The maximal cardiopulmonary exercise test (CPX) with a 12-lead electrocardiogram and expired gas analysis will be conducted using a modified Gardner protocol. This protocol starts at 2.0 mph and 0.0% grade and increases by 2.0% grade every 2 minutes at each stage .
Prior to commencing the protocol, participants will be familiarized with the Borg rating of perceived exertion scale as well as the claudication pain scale. Resting measures of gastrocnemius tissue oxygenation, via NIRS, and oxygen consumption, via a metabolic cart, will be recorded.
Throughout the test, heart rate, blood pressure, NIRS, and rating of perceived exertion will be monitored. Assuming there are no adverse events, participants will walk on the treadmill until volitional exhaustion. These participants will likely be limited by leg claudication pain and, therefore, we expect to attain a VO2peak, rather than a maximum.
Measures of Pain-Free Walking Time and Maximal Exercise Capacity
The measure of pain-free walking time will be recorded as the total time walked prior to the onset of claudication pain. During the max CPX, participants will be instructed to inform a research team member when they first feel pain in their leg during exercise—this will be recorded as COT. PWT will be recorded as the total time (in seconds) that the participant walked on the treadmill. VO2peak will be the average of the last 30 seconds of exercise.
Nitric Oxide Bioavailability Measurement (Plasma Nitrite Changes)
Prior to beginning the max CPX, a 20-gauge intravenous catheter will be placed in an antecubital vein. Approximately 5 mL of blood will be taken prior to the max CPX testing (Pre) and at 10 minutes following exercise termination (Post). Samples will then be separated into five 1 mL Eppendorf tubes containing 5 µL heparin (1-1000 U/mL) and centrifuged at 5000 g for 3-4 minutes . Afterward, the plasma will be removed into five separate tubes, snap-frozen in liquid nitrogen, and stored at -80°C until analysis.
All NO metabolite concentrations will be measured within 30 minutes of defrosting by chemiluminescence using the NOA 280 nitric oxide analyzer (Sievers Instruments) as per the manufacturer’s instructions. The reductant used for nitrite analysis will be potassium iodide in acetic acid, which has the reduction potential to convert nitrite to NO; this reductant is insufficient to reduce any higher oxides of nitrogen such as nitrate and, thus, is relatively specific for nitrite. To obtain concentrations of total plasma nitrogen oxides, we will use the same apparatus with a stronger reductant, vanadium chloride in 1 M HCl, at 94°C. This reduces the sum of all nitrogen oxides with an oxidation state of +2 or higher, which is predominantly nitrate (µM), but also includes both nitrite (nM) and nitrosothiols (nM).
Tissue Oxygenation Measurement (Near-Infrared Spectroscopy)
NIRS has been shown to be a reproducible and reliable method to determine tissue oxygen stores in human skeletal muscle tissue . The NIRS PortaMon device (Artinis Medical Systems) is a noninvasive portable tool for measuring tissue oxygenation. It works by emitting near-infrared light wavelengths of 760 nm and 850 nm that correspond to the absorption spectra of hemoglobin (Hb) and deoxygenated Hb, respectively. Depending on the oxygenation status of the tissues (ie, how much oxygenated vs deoxygenated Hb is present), the resultant spectra will change and the light fraction will be captured by a detector on the device itself [ ]. This technique provides continuous snapshots of the muscle tissue oxygenation as well as percent oxygen saturation.
The tissue oxygenation will be assessed utilizing the NIRS device to obtain an index of fractional oxygen extraction—[deoxy(Hb + myoglobin)]—and percent oxygen saturation at rest at the beginning of the exercise test and continuously monitored throughout the max CPX and recovery period .
For the vascular testing visit, subjects will be instructed to withhold all medications and consume no food for 8 hours prior to the exam. All vascular testing will be performed between 8 am and 11 am in a temperature-controlled room following 10-15 minutes of quiet relaxation.
Endothelial Function (Brachial Artery Flow-Mediated Dilation)
Endothelial dysfunction is a precursor to the development of atherosclerosis and an independent predictor of cardiovascular events and clinical outcomes . Brachial artery flow-mediated dilation is the most commonly used noninvasive measure for the assessment of endothelial function [ ]. This technique relies on the reactive hyperemic response where there is an increase in arterial blood flow following a period of ischemia (ie, occlusion). The dilation of the artery—typically the brachial artery is imaged—represents, in part, the NO-mediated arterial response to sheer stress [ , ]. All imaging will be performed at the brachial artery of the left arm with the subject in a supine position, with the forearm extended and slightly supinated. All image captures will be r-wave triggered. Two 10-second video-captures of the brachial artery will be obtained at baseline (resting), and then 2 minutes of continuous imaging will be recorded following 5 minutes of distal forearm occlusion (reactive hyperemia). Absolute and relative changes in brachial artery diameter will be calculated as follows:
Absolute and relative changes in brachial artery diameter = (peak posthyperemia diastolic diameter − baseline diastolic diameter)/baseline diastolic diameter × 100 (1)
Central blood pressures—the pressures by which the internal organs are perfused—have been shown to be strongly related to clinical outcomes . A specially designed brachial cuff will be utilized to capture brachial systolic and diastolic pressure as well as the pulse waveform. The SphygmoCor software version 8.0 (AtCor Medical) will then use a validated generalized transfer function to derive central diastolic and systolic blood pressure, mean arterial pressure and pressure product along with the pressure augmentation (ΔP) due to wave reflection, and the pressure augmentation index (AIx):
AIx = ΔP/pulse pressure × 100 (2)
To capture PWV, sequential measurements of arterial pressure waves will be taken at the carotid artery, using applanation tonometry, and femoral artery, using a specialized thigh cuff. The surface distances from the sternal notch to the carotid and femoral sites will be measured and input into the software for calculation of the PWV. Pressure wave transit times to each site will be measured using the foot-of-the-wave method:
Distance of pulse wave (DPW) = sternal notch distance to femoral artery − carotid artery distance to sternal notch (3)
Carotid − femoral PWV = DPW/transit time(s) (4)
The ankle-brachial index (ABI) is the ratio of blood pressure in the feet in comparison to the arms and is linked with mortality and morbidity rates [, ]. Measurements will be obtained on both the left and right side of each subject. A 5-7 MHz handheld Doppler probe coupled with a BP cuff—positioned proximal to the probe—will be used to detect blood flow through the arteries. On each arm, the brachial artery will be occluded at the biceps using an appropriately sized BP cuff, while the Doppler probe will be placed over the brachial artery to detect blood flow. An additional cuff will be placed approximately 3 cm above the medial malleolus in order to occlude the anterior tibial (AT) artery. The AT artery bifurcates in the foot into the dorsalis pedis (DP) and the posterior tibialis (PT) arteries, so both the DP and PT arteries will be measured separately via Doppler after occlusion of the AT artery using the BP cuff. The average of the least two separate measurements will be taken at each artery. The ABI value will be calculated by dividing the higher average DP or PT value from each side by the highest average radial artery value obtained from either side [ ].
Lower-Limb Blood Flow
Following the ABI procedure, the participant will be kept supine throughout the plethysmography measurements. Lower-limb blood flow will be assessed both at rest and following reactive hyperemia via the use of a Hokanson A16 mercury-in-silastic strain gauge plethysmograph (Hokanson Inc). Initial setup requires the patient to lie supine, with the legs elevated slightly above the level of the heart to facilitate venous emptying. Two BP cuffs will be placed on the upper thigh of the leg to be assessed: one will be used for arterial occlusion and one for venous occlusion. A mercury-in-silastic strain gauge will be placed around the widest part of the calf to allow for the indirect measurement of blood flow via changes in lower-limb diameter. Resting measures will be acquired by inflating and deflating the venous occlusion thigh cuffs to approximately 50 mmHg (ie, just above venous pressure) every 10 seconds for five cycles. During inflation, the mercury-in-silastic strain gauge will be placed under stress, which will then be graphically represented as a pressure response curve on the Hokanson A16 machine. The average of three resting measures will be used as the baseline arterial inflow measure. Following 5 minutes of rest, the thigh cuff will be inflated to 30 mmHg above systolic pressure to induce arterial occlusion for 5 minutes. Upon release of the occlusion cuff, the same procedure used for resting measures will be initiated whereby the venous occlusion cuff will be inflated and deflated to create a pressure response curve for blood flow following reactive hyperemia .
Gastrocnemius Muscle Biopsy
Prior to muscle biopsies, all subjects will be asked to refrain from anticoagulant medications. Samples from the gastrocnemius muscle will be obtained using the Bergstrom percutaneous needle biopsy technique. Biopsy sites will be anesthetized with a 2% Xylocaine solution and a 0.5 cm incision will be made through the skin and fascia. Separate samples will be taken with approximately five passes of the needle into the muscle. All samples will then be prepared immediately by weighing and then dividing the samples for later analysis. A tissue sample of approximately 100 mg is consistently obtained with a triple pass from a single insertion; we have demonstrated that this amount of tissue is sufficient for analyzing muscle fiber composition and angiogenesis. Visible blood and connective tissue will be removed and the specimens divided longitudinally. Portions for RNA (40 mg) analyses will be frozen in liquid nitrogen and stored at -70°C. Another portion to be used for histochemical analysis (~30 mg) will be oriented such that the fibers run longitudinally, mounted on cork-embedding medium (OCT compound), and frozen in isopentane cooled with liquid nitrogen.
For the analysis of the muscle tissue, after thawing the tissue, measurements will be taken for markers of angiogenesis including the following: capillaries per unit area and per muscle fiber, endothelial cells with surrounding pericytes, and relative fraction of type I, IIa, IIb, and IId/x fibers. Additionally, oxidative capacity of the fibers will be quantified via mitochondrial volume with citrate synthase activity.
Informed consent has been obtained from each patient and the study has been approved by the Duke University School of Medicine Institutional Review Board. The study is being run under an Investigational New Drug application filed with the US Food and Drug Administration.
Statistical Analysis Plan
This is a repeated-measures design, with the purpose of assessing change over time for the two intervention groups. Since this is a pilot study, the overarching goal of the analyses is to derive effect sizes (ie, effectiveness) for this intervention for a future larger, confirmatory study. We will conduct the analyses chronologically in three phases: (1) descriptive analyses of dependent and independent variables; (2) bivariate analyses of the association between group membership and the outcome measures; and (3) controlled multivariable analyses, which assess the association between groups and the outcomes controlling for important covariates. Randomization should ensure the groups are initially equal; however, we will control for important baseline variables, including the two outcomes of interest. We will not control for any variables observed postrandomization . Our general analytic strategy will be to employ these models to assess differences between groups and, most importantly, assess the differences in change over time between the groups. Our general baseline model will have the following form:
Y it = β 0 + β 1 (Group) + β 2 (Time t) + β 3 (Group × Time t) + β 4 (Covariates it) + ε it (5)
where Yit is the change in the outcome over the time points, t is an indicator of change period (t=2,4) depending on the wave of measurement, and i is an indicator of the individual (i=1,24). β1 is an indicator variable indicating group membership. β2 is an indicator variable indicating the time of testing: baseline, baseline on supplement, postintervention on supplement, and postintervention off supplement. β3 is a Group × Timet interaction. As listed, β4 is a vector of regression weights linking the design matrix of covariates—time varying and time invariant—to the outcome of interest. We will center Timet=0 at the final 12-week time point, which will allow us to test if there are differences at the end of the trial, β1=0. Follow-up analyses will assess the impact of Group × Timet interaction and the functional form of the change over time. Inclusion of covariates into the model, including baseline measures, may add precision to the estimates and allow us to assess the generalizability of the effects across the covariates. The list of covariates (eg, age, gender, health events, comorbidity, and medications) will be developed prior to any analysis. This is a small sample (n=24); hence, the number of covariates we can utilize in any regression is minimal: ≈10 cases per variable . We will assess the impact of each potential covariate individually without respect to group and, if significant (P=.10), it will be retained in models with Group, Timet, and Group × Timet (see above).
This is a pilot study and we do not expect to declare statistical significance for any of the variables assessed under this analytic structure. However, if the target 12 subjects per group is attained—EX+BR and EX+PL; 24 total subjects—and if a power of 80% with alpha set to .05 (two-tailed) is used, then we will be able to detect a 0.826 standardized difference in the difference in the change labeled as “large” in the statistical power literature . We will not control for the type I error risk inherent in testing multiple outcomes. Rather, should any outcome be declared significant, the reader will be alerted to the number of tests performed and the risk in drawing definitive conclusions with multiple outcomes and a small sample size.
As noted previously, the results from this pilot study will be used to power a subsequent, larger, adequately powered confirmatory clinical trial of the impact of beetroot juice on the outcomes listed above. The results, along with theory and clinical significance, will guide the choice of the primary outcome(s) for that trial, with appropriate control for type I error. While the results of this pilot study will prove useful in the calculation of power, we are aware of the many risks of “playing the winner” in choosing to power a subsequent trial from pilot study results only [, ].
Data collection from this study has been completed and is in the process of analysis and write-up. While the study is too underpowered—EX+BR, n=11; EX+PL, n=13—to determine between-group differences in the primary outcomes of COT, PWT, and 6MW, preliminary observations are promising with Cohen d effect sizes of medium to large.
Improving pain-free walking and exercise capacity are key goals for the treatment and rehabilitation of patients with peripheral arterial disease . This study aims to determine if the combined intervention of the current best treatment for PAD (ie, supervised exercise training) in conjunction with inorganic nitrate supplementation using beetroot juice can increase exercise tolerance more than exercise training alone (ie, placebo supplement).
The physiological basis for this trial relies on the fact that supplementation with inorganic nitrate will lead to increased plasma nitrite that can be transported throughout the circulation and is reduced to NO in tissue with a low partial pressure of oxygen. This hypoxic tissue-targeting effect may be particularly pertinent for patients with PAD+IC experiencing tissue ischemia during exercise participation. While it is well established that consuming inorganic nitrate increases circulating levels of plasma nitrite [, ], research on the corresponding effect on key clinical outcomes such as exercise performance in clinical patients, while promising, is still limited [ , , ].
There are three mechanisms that lend support to nitrate supplementations’ clinical utility in improving exercise performance in patients with PAD. First, acute supplementation data suggest that increasing plasma nitrite via beetroot juice improves ischemic tissue perfusion leading to increases in pain-free walking time and aerobic function . Second, increased exercise time or intensity will facilitate greater training responses and tissue adaptations. Third, increased bioavailability of NO could lead to a greater tissue angiogenic response. These mechanisms are complementary to each other and may result in a greater overall exercise tolerance
The small sample size and the focus on patients with PAD+IC only limit the ability to broadly apply the results of the study to the larger PAD population and to generalize these results to subsequent studies. This study also uses a per-protocol design with the intent that data may provide the physiological proof of concept for the intervention and allow us to derive variance data and effect sizes within and between groups to inform future studies, which will utilize an intent-to-treat criterion in the analytic structure.
This study has been designed to investigate a new therapeutic approach for the treatment of PAD+IC. If successful, the results could influence current medical practice for these patients, while also providing mechanistic insights into potential physiologic targets for other interventions. Research clearly identifies supervised exercise training as being one of the most effective interventions for improving exercise tolerance in patients with PAD [, , ]. We hypothesize the combination of supplementation with exercise will create greater adaptations than the sum of the individual exposures alone. If true, the findings would lead to a paradigm shift in the treatment recommendations for patients with PAD.
This work is supported by grants to JDA from the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (grant Nos. R21HL111972 and R21 HL113717).
Conflicts of Interest
Multimedia Appendix 1
NIH Clinical and Integrative Cardiovascular Sciences Study Section: Peer review report.PDF File (Adobe PDF File), 60KB
- Askew CD, Parmenter B, Leicht AS, Walker PJ, Golledge J. Exercise & Sports Science Australia (ESSA) position statement on exercise prescription for patients with peripheral arterial disease and intermittent claudication. J Sci Med Sport 2014 Nov;17(6):623-629. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Hirsch AT, Haskal ZJ, Hertzer NR, Bakal CW, Creager MA, Halperin JL, American Association for Vascular Surgery, Society for Vascular Surgery, Society for Cardiovascular Angiography and Interventions, Society for Vascular Medicine and Biology, Society of Interventional Radiology, ACC/AHA Task Force on Practice Guidelines Writing Committee to Develop Guidelines for the Management of Patients With Peripheral Arterial Disease, American Association of Cardiovascular and Pulmonary Rehabilitation, National Heart‚ Lung‚ and Blood Institute, Society for Vascular Nursing, TransAtlantic Inter-Society Consensus, Vascular Disease Foundation. ACC/AHA 2005 Practice Guidelines for the management of patients with peripheral arterial disease (lower extremity, renal, mesenteric, and abdominal aortic): A collaborative report from the American Association for Vascular Surgery/Society for Vascular Surgery, Society for Cardiovascular Angiography and Interventions, Society for Vascular Medicine and Biology, Society of Interventional Radiology, and the ACC/AHA Task Force on Practice Guidelines (Writing Committee to Develop Guidelines for the Management of Patients With Peripheral Arterial Disease): Endorsed by the American Association of Cardiovascular and Pulmonary Rehabilitation; National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute; Society for Vascular Nursing; TransAtlantic Inter-Society Consensus; and Vascular Disease Foundation. Circulation 2006 Mar 21;113(11):e463-e654 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Olsen PS, Gustafsen J, Rasmussen L, Lorentzen JE. Long-term results after arterial surgery for arteriosclerosis of the lower limbs in young adults. Eur J Vasc Surg 1988 Feb;2(1):15-18. [Medline]
- Lloyd-Jones D, Adams RJ, Brown TM, Carnethon M, Dai S, De Simone G, American Heart Association Statistics Committee and Stroke Statistics Subcommittee. Heart disease and stroke statistics--2010 update: A report from the American Heart Association. Circulation 2010 Feb 23;121(7):e46-e215 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Milani RV, Lavie CJ. The role of exercise training in peripheral arterial disease. Vasc Med 2007 Nov;12(4):351-358. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Murphy TP, Cutlip DE, Regensteiner JG, Mohler ER, Cohen DJ, Reynolds MR, et al. Supervised exercise versus primary stenting for claudication resulting from aortoiliac peripheral artery disease: Six-month outcomes from the Claudication: Exercise Versus Endoluminal Revascularization (CLEVER) study. Circulation 2012 Jan 03;125(1):130-139 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Patterson RB, Pinto B, Marcus B, Colucci A, Braun T, Roberts M. Value of a supervised exercise program for the therapy of arterial claudication. J Vasc Surg 1997 Feb;25(2):312-318; discussion 318 [FREE Full text] [Medline]
- Albright A, Franz M, Hornsby G, Kriska A, Marrero D, Ullrich I, et al. American College of Sports Medicine position stand. Exercise and type 2 diabetes. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2000 Jul;32(7):1345-1360. [Medline]
- Boulé NG, Haddad E, Kenny G, Wells G, Sigal R. Effects of exercise on glycemic control and body mass in type 2 diabetes mellitus: A meta-analysis of controlled clinical trials. JAMA 2001 Sep 12;286(10):1218-1227. [Medline]
- Fagard RH. Exercise characteristics and the blood pressure response to dynamic physical training. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2001 Jun;33(6 Suppl):S484-S492; discussion S493. [Medline]
- Leon AS, Rice T, Mandel S, Després JP, Bergeron J, Gagnon J, et al. Blood lipid response to 20 weeks of supervised exercise in a large biracial population: The HERITAGE Family Study. Metabolism 2000 Apr;49(4):513-520. [Medline]
- Sigal RJ, Kenny GP, Boulé NG, Wells GA, Prud'homme D, Fortier M, et al. Effects of aerobic training, resistance training, or both on glycemic control in type 2 diabetes: A randomized trial. Ann Intern Med 2007 Sep 18;147(6):357-369. [Medline]
- Stefanick ML, Mackey S, Sheehan M, Ellsworth N, Haskell WL, Wood PD. Effects of diet and exercise in men and postmenopausal women with low levels of HDL cholesterol and high levels of LDL cholesterol. N Engl J Med 1998 Jul 02;339(1):12-20. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Stewart K. Exercise training and the cardiovascular consequences of type 2 diabetes and hypertension: Plausible mechanisms for improving cardiovascular health. JAMA 2002 Oct 02;288(13):1622-1631. [Medline]
- Brevetti G, Schiano V, Chiariello M. Endothelial dysfunction: A key to the pathophysiology and natural history of peripheral arterial disease? Atherosclerosis 2008 Mar;197(1):1-11. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Pipinos II, Sharov VG, Shepard AD, Anagnostopoulos PV, Katsamouris A, Todor A, et al. Abnormal mitochondrial respiration in skeletal muscle in patients with peripheral arterial disease. J Vasc Surg 2003 Oct;38(4):827-832 [FREE Full text] [Medline]
- Robbins JL, Jones WS, Duscha BD, Allen JD, Kraus WE, Regensteiner JG, et al. Relationship between leg muscle capillary density and peak hyperemic blood flow with endurance capacity in peripheral artery disease. J Appl Physiol (1985) 2011 Jul;111(1):81-86 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Pipinos II, Shepard AD, Anagnostopoulos PV, Katsamouris A, Boska MD. Phosphorus 31 nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy suggests a mitochondrial defect in claudicating skeletal muscle. J Vasc Surg 2000 May;31(5):944-952 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Duscha BD, Robbins JL, Jones WS, Kraus WE, Lye RJ, Sanders JM, et al. Angiogenesis in skeletal muscle precede improvements in peak oxygen uptake in peripheral artery disease patients. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol 2011 Nov;31(11):2742-2748 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Allen JD, Stabler T, Kenjale A, Ham KL, Robbins JL, Duscha BD, et al. Plasma nitrite flux predicts exercise performance in peripheral arterial disease after 3 months of exercise training. Free Radic Biol Med 2010 Sep 15;49(6):1138-1144. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Brevetti G, Silvestro A, Schiano V, Chiariello M. Endothelial dysfunction and cardiovascular risk prediction in peripheral arterial disease: Additive value of flow-mediated dilation to ankle-brachial pressure index. Circulation 2003 Oct 28;108(17):2093-2098 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- de Haro Miralles J, Martínez-Aguilar E, Florez A, Varela C, Bleda S, Acin F. Nitric oxide: Link between endothelial dysfunction and inflammation in patients with peripheral arterial disease of the lower limbs. Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 2009 Jul;9(1):107-112. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Modin A, Björne H, Herulf M, Alving K, Weitzberg E, Lundberg JO. Nitrite-derived nitric oxide: A possible mediator of 'acidic-metabolic' vasodilation. Acta Physiol Scand 2001 Jan;171(1):9-16. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Kapil V, Milsom AB, Okorie M, Maleki-Toyserkani S, Akram F, Rehman F, et al. Inorganic nitrate supplementation lowers blood pressure in humans: Role for nitrite-derived NO. Hypertension 2010 Aug;56(2):274-281 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Tannenbaum SR, Weisman M, Fett D. The effect of nitrate intake on nitrite formation in human saliva. Food Cosmet Toxicol 1976 Dec;14(6):549-552. [Medline]
- Cermak NM, Gibala MJ, van Loon LJ. Nitrate supplementation's improvement of 10-km time-trial performance in trained cyclists. Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab 2012 Feb;22(1):64-71. [Medline]
- Kenjale AA, Ham KL, Stabler T, Robbins JL, Johnson JL, Vanbruggen M, et al. Dietary nitrate supplementation enhances exercise performance in peripheral arterial disease. J Appl Physiol (1985) 2011 Jun;110(6):1582-1591 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Lansley KE, Winyard PG, Fulford J, Vanhatalo A, Bailey SJ, Blackwell JR, et al. Dietary nitrate supplementation reduces the O2 cost of walking and running: A placebo-controlled study. J Appl Physiol (1985) 2011 Mar;110(3):591-600 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Larsen FJ, Weitzberg E, Lundberg JO, Ekblom B. Dietary nitrate reduces maximal oxygen consumption while maintaining work performance in maximal exercise. Free Radic Biol Med 2010 Jan 15;48(2):342-347. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Pinna M, Roberto S, Milia R, Marongiu E, Olla S, Loi A, et al. Effect of beetroot juice supplementation on aerobic response during swimming. Nutrients 2014 Jan 29;6(2):605-615 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Bailey SJ, Winyard P, Vanhatalo A, Blackwell JR, Dimenna FJ, Wilkerson DP, et al. Dietary nitrate supplementation reduces the O2 cost of low-intensity exercise and enhances tolerance to high-intensity exercise in humans. J Appl Physiol (1985) 2009 Oct;107(4):1144-1155 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Wilkerson DP, Hayward GM, Bailey SJ, Vanhatalo A, Blackwell JR, Jones AM. Influence of acute dietary nitrate supplementation on 50 mile time trial performance in well-trained cyclists. Eur J Appl Physiol 2012 Dec;112(12):4127-4134. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Peacock O, Tjønna AE, James P, Wisløff U, Welde B, Böhlke N, et al. Dietary nitrate does not enhance running performance in elite cross-country skiers. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2012 Nov;44(11):2213-2219. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Boorsma RK, Whitfield J, Spriet LL. Beetroot juice supplementation does not improve performance of elite 1500-m runners. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2014 Dec;46(12):2326-2334. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Porcelli S, Ramaglia M, Bellistri G, Pavei G, Pugliese L, Montorsi M, et al. Aerobic fitness affects the exercise performance responses to nitrate supplementation. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2015 Aug;47(8):1643-1651. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Coggan AR, Leibowitz JL, Spearie CA, Kadkhodayan A, Thomas DP, Ramamurthy S, et al. Acute dietary nitrate intake improves muscle contractile function in patients with heart failure: A double-blind, placebo-controlled, randomized trial. Circ Heart Fail 2015 Sep;8(5):914-920 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Eggebeen J, Kim-Shapiro DB, Haykowsky M, Morgan TM, Basu S, Brubaker P, et al. One week of daily dosing with beetroot juice improves submaximal endurance and blood pressure in older patients with heart failure and preserved ejection fraction. JACC Heart Fail 2016 Jun;4(6):428-437 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Zamani P, Rawat D, Shiva-Kumar P, Geraci S, Bhuva R, Konda P, et al. Effect of inorganic nitrate on exercise capacity in heart failure with preserved ejection fraction. Circulation 2015 Jan 27;131(4):371-380; discussion 380 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Berry MJ, Justus NW, Hauser JI, Case AH, Helms CC, Basu S, et al. Dietary nitrate supplementation improves exercise performance and decreases blood pressure in COPD patients. Nitric Oxide 2015 Aug 01;48:22-30 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Hirai DM, Zelt JT, Jones JH, Castanhas LG, Bentley RF, Earle W, et al. Dietary nitrate supplementation and exercise tolerance in patients with heart failure with reduced ejection fraction. Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol 2017 Jan 01;312(1):R13-R22. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Jungersten L, Edlund A, Petersson AS, Wennmalm A. Plasma nitrate as an index of nitric oxide formation in man: Analyses of kinetics and confounding factors. Clin Physiol 1996 Jul;16(4):369-379. [Medline]
- Gardner AW, Afaq A. Management of lower extremity peripheral arterial disease. J Cardiopulm Rehabil Prev 2008;28(6):349-357 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Allan RB, Delaney CL, Miller MD, Spark JI. A comparison of flow-mediated dilatation and peripheral artery tonometry for measurement of endothelial function in healthy individuals and patients with peripheral arterial disease. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg 2013 Mar;45(3):263-269 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Deanfield JE, Halcox JP, Rabelink TJ. Endothelial function and dysfunction: Testing and clinical relevance. Circulation 2007 Mar 13;115(10):1285-1295 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Gokce N, Keaney JF, Hunter LM, Watkins MT, Nedeljkovic ZS, Menzoian JO, et al. Predictive value of noninvasively determined endothelial dysfunction for long-term cardiovascular events in patients with peripheral vascular disease. J Am Coll Cardiol 2003 May 21;41(10):1769-1775 [FREE Full text] [Medline]
- Williams B, Lacy PS, Thom SM, Cruickshank K, Stanton A, Collier D, Anglo-Scandinavian Cardiac Outcomes Trial Investigators, CAFE Steering Committee and Writing Committee. Differential impact of blood pressure-lowering drugs on central aortic pressure and clinical outcomes: Principal results of the Conduit Artery Function Evaluation (CAFE) study. Circulation 2006 Mar 07;113(9):1213-1225 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Paraskevas KI, Kotsikoris I, Koupidis SA, Giannoukas AD, Mikhailidis DP. Ankle-brachial index: A marker of both peripheral arterial disease and systemic atherosclerosis as well as a predictor of vascular events. Angiology 2010 Aug;61(6):521-523. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Resnick HE, Lindsay RS, McDermott MM, Devereux RB, Jones KL, Fabsitz RR, et al. Relationship of high and low ankle-brachial index to all-cause and cardiovascular disease mortality: The Strong Heart Study. Circulation 2004 Feb 17;109(6):733-739 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Cohen J. Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. 2nd edition. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates; 1988.
- Kraemer HC, Mintz J, Noda A, Tinklenberg J, Yesavage JA. Caution regarding the use of pilot studies to guide power calculations for study proposals. Arch Gen Psychiatry 2006 May;63(5):484-489. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Leon AC, Davis LL, Kraemer HC. The role and interpretation of pilot studies in clinical research. J Psychiatr Res 2011 May;45(5):626-629 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Larsen FJ, Weitzberg E, Lundberg JO, Ekblom B. Effects of dietary nitrate on oxygen cost during exercise. Acta Physiol (Oxf) 2007 Sep;191(1):59-66. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Gardner AW, Poehlman ET. Exercise rehabilitation programs for the treatment of claudication pain. A meta-analysis. JAMA 1995 Sep 27;274(12):975-980. [Medline]
- Watson L, Ellis B, Leng GC. Exercise for intermittent claudication. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2008 Oct 08(4):CD000990. [CrossRef] [Medline]
|6MW: 6-minute walk|
|ABI: ankle-brachial index|
|AIx: augmentation index|
|AT: anterior tibial|
|BP: blood pressure|
|COT: claudication onset time|
|CPX: cardiopulmonary exercise test|
|ΔP: pressure augmentation|
|DP: dorsalis pedis|
|DPW: distance of pulse wave|
|EX+BR: exercise training plus beetroot juice|
|EX+PL: exercise training plus placebo juice|
|IC: intermittent claudication|
|max CPX: maximal-graded cardiopulmonary exercise test|
|NIRS: near-infrared spectroscopy|
|NO: nitric oxide|
|PAD: peripheral artery disease|
|PAD+IC: peripheral artery disease with intermittent claudication|
|PT: posterior tibialis|
|PWT: peak walk time|
|PWV: pulse wave velocity|
|VO 2peak: peak oxygen uptake|
Edited by G Eysenbach; submitted 12.03.17; peer-reviewed by S Porcelli, A Webb, B Piknova; comments to author 17.05.17; revised version received 25.05.17; accepted 26.05.17; published 03.10.17
©Mary N Woessner, Mitch D VanBruggen, Carl F Pieper, Erin K O'Reilly, William E Kraus, Jason D Allen. Originally published in JMIR Research Protocols (http://www.researchprotocols.org), 03.10.2017.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work, first published in JMIR Research Protocols, is properly cited. The complete bibliographic information, a link to the original publication on http://www.researchprotocols.org, as well as this copyright and license information must be included.