The SADI Personal Health Lens: A Web Browser-Based System for Identifying Personally Relevant Drug Interactions
Background: The Web provides widespread access to vast quantities of health-related information that can improve quality-of-life through better understanding of personal symptoms, medical conditions, and available treatments. Unfortunately, identifying a credible and personally relevant subset of information can be a time-consuming and challenging task for users without a medical background.
Objective: The objective of the Personal Health Lens system is to aid users when reading health-related webpages by providing warnings about personally relevant drug interactions. More broadly, we wish to present a prototype for a novel, generalizable approach to facilitating interactions between a patient, their practitioner(s), and the Web.
Methods: We utilized a distributed, Semantic Web-based architecture for recognizing personally dangerous drugs consisting of: (1) a private, local triple store of personal health information, (2) Semantic Web services, following the Semantic Automated Discovery and Integration (SADI) design pattern, for text mining and identifying substance interactions, (3) a bookmarklet to trigger analysis of a webpage and annotate it with personalized warnings, and (4) a semantic query that acts as an abstract template of the analytical workflow to be enacted by the system.
Conclusions: The main strength of the Personal Health Lens system is its ability to organize medical information and to present it to the user in a personalized and contextually relevant manner. While this prototype was limited to a single knowledge domain (drug/drug interactions), the proposed architecture is generalizable, and could act as the foundation for much richer personalized-health-Web clients, while importantly providing a novel and personalizable mechanism for clinical experts to inject their expertise into the browsing experience of their patients in the form of customized semantic queries and ontologies.
JMIR Res Protoc 2013;2(1):e14)
- drug interactions;
- Web-based services;
- Web-based interaction;
- semantic Web;
For the lay-person, free health information on the Web is a potentially valuable resource for better understanding personal symptoms, medical conditions, drugs, and nutrition. However, while sites such as WebMD  provide accredited sources of information, a multitude of other sources such as blogs, Wikipedia articles, and news articles exist that provide no guarantees about their completeness, accuracy, or objectivity. Thus, distinguishing between reliable and unreliable information is a central issue. However, even when restricted to verified sources, the sheer quantity of available material often makes meaningful interpretation a challenging task for readers without a medical background. For example, a study published by White and Horvitz in 2009 demonstrated a phenomenon known as “cyberchondria”, wherein a person experiences a heightened anxiety about medical conditions after reviewing search results and online literature relating to common symptoms (eg, headache [ ]). Finally, the issue of “information quality” is both personal and subjective—information that is relevant for one individual might not be relevant to another, based on personal factors such as overall health, drug-regimen or other interventions, lifestyle, gender, or even personal interest. As observed by Burgess et al, “due to the unique nature of every individual, a single…method that assumes all people are the same will fail to meet every person’s information needs” [ ]. It would be highly desirable, therefore, to assist Web users by filtering and/or annotating the information they encounter on the Web in a personalized way, thereby increasing its relevance and utility to that individual. Moreover, given that a patient may be at any point in their continuum-of-care, it would be particularly desirable to provide the patient’s clinical-care team an opportunity to include their “voice” into that annotation and filtering mechanism, such that the clinician’s plan for that patient enhances the personalization of the page even further.
We recently published a novel framework for automatically synthesizing contextually-sensitive data retrieval and analysis workflows composed of dynamically-selected Semantic Web Services . The system used a semantic template describing the abstract “intent” of the workflow, combined with the specific details in a given dataset, to concretize an appropriate workflow capable of evaluating that data. In this work we intend to demonstrate, using a straightforward prototype application called the Semantic Automated Discovery and Integration (SADI) Personal Health Lens, that these components—the data, the semantic model, and the derived analytical workflow—map directly onto the various facets of the Health Web personalization problem described above. The Personal Health Lens application utilizes the patient’s individual medical history and data, the clinician’s plan for that patient (in the form of a semantic query), and publicly available tools that can be automatically selected and appropriately chained-together to analyze and contextually interpret the content of a webpage. The output is an annotated page containing new information specifically relevant to that patient, which is loaded into their browser as usual.
Personalization of Web information necessitates the use of the individual’s personal medical profile, since this information can be used to identify both relevant and inappropriate advice within a webpage. There has been considerable work in the area of semantic representation of electronic patient records, both institutional  and personal [ ], and a variety of different standards exist for the content and structure of these records. Here, we do not intend to prescribe or proscribe any particular standard. This work simply assumes that such health records exist, are accessible to the local browser, and are (or can be) expressed in standard Semantic Web syntaxes. As the various models for electronic health records begin to consolidate, the prototype system could be easily re-written to conform to that standard. For the purposes of this prototype, we created a simple model of the drug-regime portion of the patient’s health record, along with several other clinical and personal features.
Much of the prior work in “personalization” of a patient’s Web experience has been in the domain of facilitated search, particularly through the use of semantically-backed personal health portals (eg, [, ]) where the role of semantics in the portal is either for search-expansion to discover additional relevant pages, and/or to simplify medical terminology for the patient while still providing access to complex literature. While portals allow a much higher degree of potential curation by experts, thus (presumably) improving information quality, they also require a much higher level of buy-in from the patient, who must choose to exclusively visit the portal for their health information in lieu of more typical forms of Web exploration such as search engines and browsing. Moreover, though a portal may provide access to a curated or filtered set of pages, the pages themselves are generally untouched; we were unable to identify any personal health portal in which the source pages were, themselves, contextually marked-up. We believe that context is an important part of the personalization experience, as is the freedom to explore the Web in any manner the patient chooses. The Personal Health Lens, therefore, was designed to operate over any page, at any time, discovered in any manner, and places its patient-oriented annotations directly into the page-context. This is achieved by utilizing the semantics—both in the patient’s data, as well as in a semantic template query—to generate a contextually-relevant Semantic Web Service-based annotation workflow at the moment the Health Lens is invoked. This workflow may differ depending on the patient’s medical information and the content of the page they are viewing, thus providing the flexibility necessary to operate on the open Web, rather than through a curated portal.
We now describe in detail our prototype system that attempts to identify drugs within the online literature that are potentially dangerous to the user based on their personal health record. We begin by giving an overview of the system and a description of the prototype implementation in the Methods section. In the Results section, we demonstrate use of the prototype in the context of a sample health profile. Finally, we discuss some high-level design issues and provide closing remarks in the Discussion section.
Use of Semantic Web Standards and Technologies
RDF, OWL, SADI, and SHARE
All data within the Health Lens system were represented using the Resource Description Framework (RDF) model , which provides significant advantages over other formats such as Extensible Markup Language XML and ad hoc text formats when integrating data across multiple sources. In particular, RDF allows the assignment of globally unique identifiers (URIs) to all entities within the data, making it possible to match entities across distributed data sets in a reliable manner. Further, RDF supports an automated procedure called RDF-Merge [ ] for merging data sets into a single file or database, regardless of the actual content of the data sets involved. This significantly reduced the cost of developing a database for the system, and will also reduce the cost of maintenance when adding new data sources in the future. Finally, in contrast to other data models, RDF data sets are not constrained to a fixed schema. This property of RDF allows any type of statement to be added to an existing data set without adversely affecting clients or servers that use that data set. For instance, in Health Lens, the use of RDF to represent the personal health profile will allow any new type of health data to be added to the profile in the future without requiring an update to the database schema or the interfaces of the various system components.
The Web Ontology Language (OWL)  also played a central role in the design of the Health Lens system, providing a general framework for describing and processing logical constraints about RDF data. The chief advantage of using OWL in the context of the Health Lens project is that data matchmaking and validation tasks can be performed by a reusable tool called an OWL reasoner (eg, [ ]), rather than by custom, application-specific software.
The Health Lens system utilizes 2 Semantic Web projects that have been built on top of the RDF and OWL standards—Semantic Automated Discovery and Integration, and Semantic Health and Research Environment.
Semantic Automated Discovery and Integration (SADI)
SADI is a set of design patterns for producing stateless Web services that natively consume and produce RDF data. The structure of the input and output data for SADI services are formally described by an input OWL class and an output OWL class, respectively. Further details about SADI are described in .
Semantic Health and Research Environment (SHARE)
SHARE is a proof-of-concept Semantic Web query engine that resolves SPARQL Protocol and RDF Query Language (SPARQL, ) queries by building and executing workflows of SADI services. SHARE is also capable of discovering instances of a given OWL class by building an appropriate SADI workflow. Further details about SHARE are described in [ ].
A Note About Opaque URIs in RDF Data
Many of the URIs in the example RDF data of this paper are opaque, making human interpretation of the data considerably more difficult than if human-readable identifiers had been used. For example, the URI of the “has attribute” predicate of the Semanticscience Integrated Ontology (SIO) ontology  is http://semanticscience.org/resource/SIO_000008. The use of opaque URIs is a best practice when the uniqueness of a label for an entity cannot be guaranteed, due to the existence of synonymous labels or labels in multiple languages. By convention, human-readable labels are indicated via the rdfs:label predicate. This allows multiple labels to be assigned to the same entity, and also permits changes to the labels without adversely affecting other RDF data sets on the Web that refer to the entity in question. To aid the reader, comments are provided within the example data that provide translations from opaque URIs to human-readable labels.
The Health Lens system operates in a cycle of 3 steps, as depicted in:
- The user creates or updates his/her personal health profile, which is stored locally in the personal health database.
- The system executes a SHARE query to identify dangerous interactions between the user's personal health profile and any known drug. All discovered interactions are aggregated and stored in the personal health database for use in Step 3.
- From within a Web browser, the user clicks the Health Lens bookmarklet to identify mentions of drugs in the current webpage that may be personally dangerous. The bookmarklet accomplishes this by (a) identifying drug mentions within the text using one or more SADI entity recognition services, and (b) comparing the identified drugs against the list of drugs that have interactions with the personal health profile, as computed in Step 2.
The circular arrows ofindicate that Steps 1-3 occur in a repeating cycle; each time the user changes his/her profile (eg, adding a new prescription), Step 2 must be rerun to rebuild the full set of known interactions with the profile.
Step 1: Creating/Updating the Personal Health Profile
Our prototype implementation of the Health Lens system includes a sample personal health profile (). The profile is provided as an RDF/N3 file, and describes a 37-year-old female named Jane Doe who is on a prescription for Alprazolam (Xanax), a member of the benzodiazepine class of psychoactive drugs that is commonly used to treat anxiety disorders.
While the current focus of the profile is drug prescriptions, the use of RDF will allow future extension of the profile to include personal data such as allergies, medical conditions, diet, clinical test results, and genotyping.
Currently, changes to the health profile must be made by editing the RDF/N3 file by hand; however, any future versions of the system will provide a user interface for this task. The schema for the sample health profile uses a combination of Friend of a Friend (FOAF) , an ontology for describing people and their relationships, and the SIO [ ], an upper level ontology for representing scientific data. The main subject of the profile, Jane Doe, is represented by a blank node (“[ ]”) with an rdf:type of foaf:Person, and this node has a combination of FOAF and DBPedia [ ] properties indicating first name, last name, gender, and date of birth. A prescription node is attached to the Jane Doe node by the med:prescription property, and this node has attached attributes indicating the prescribed drug, quantity, dosage, and date of prescription.
Step 2: Precomputing Dangerous Drug Interactions
In order to access dangerous drug interactions, we developed a drug-drug interaction (DDI) discovery SADI service. For the backend data, a small data set of approximately 40 known drug interactions with St. John’s Wort, a herbal treatment for depression, was constructed manually from the literature. The authors chose to use a hand-constructed data set for the initial version of the project because they were unsuccessful in finding a curated public resource with all of the required details of the interactions, namely directionality, supporting citations, and coded clinical effects. The databases that came closest to meeting the requirements were DrugBank , which describes clinical effects in natural language, the Twosides [ ] PharmGKB database, which provides only computationally-predicted interactions, NDF-RT [ ], which does not provide access to supporting citations, and the Drug Interaction Knowledge Base (DIKB) [ ], which does not describe clinical effects. In future work, the authors may be able to replace the hand-curated St. John’s Wort data set with some combination of these resources.
Example input and output data from the DDI service are provided inand , respectively. Using the terminology of this example input/output data, the DDI discovery service takes as input a “chemical entity” (Alprazolam) that “has attribute” some “chemical identifier” and outputs an “annotated chemical entity” that “is participant in” some “drug-drug interaction”. The provided output data describes a directed drug-drug interaction between St. John’s Wort and the input drug Alprazolam, where the direction of the interaction is indicated by assigning the roles of “actor” and “target” to St. John's Wort and Alprazolam, respectively. A citation providing evidence for the interaction is attached via the SIO “has source” property, and the clinical effect of the interaction is attached via the SIO “results in” property. The effect of the interaction itself is represented using a controlled vocabulary term for “decreased efficacy of drug”. For clarity of exposition, many long auto-generated URIs (UUIDs) in the real service output data have been replaced by blank nodes in , however, the resulting RDF is semantically equivalent.
The Health Lens system invokes the drug interaction service via a SPARQL query () to a local instance of SHARE. The result of this query is the collection of all known interactions between the user’s prescribed drugs and any other drug. Using the SHARE system as the client for the drug interaction service had several advantages over implementing application-specific client code. One advantage is that new sources for interaction data can be added to the system in the future simply by adding entries to SHARE’s registry of SADI services. Another advantage is that the nature of the conflicts that are discovered by the system can be changed by modifying the SHARE query, rather than modifying the application code. For example, while the current version of the system searches for interactions with prescribed drugs, future versions might also take into account interactions with allergies or specific genotypes.
One caveat of using SHARE system for invoking the DDI service is that running the query can be time intensive. Resolving a SHARE query involves several potentially expensive operations such as downloading ontologies, performing OWL reasoning to match local data to available services, and invoking SADI services over the Web. The Health Lens system therefore runs the SHARE query “offline”; whenever the user creates or updates his/her personal health profile, the query is re-executed and the retrieved interactions are cached in the personal health database. This approach enables the user to scan a webpage and view any resulting warnings in a reasonably short amount of time.
Step 3: Identifying Dangerous Drugs in Webpages
As part of the Health Lens prototype, a SADI entity recognition service was created that identifies drug names within plain text. Example input and output RDF data for the service are provided inand , respectively. The input data for the service was modeled using a combination of the Bibliographic Ontotology (BIBO) [ ] and the Dublin Core (DC) [ ] ontology, while the output data was modeled using the FOAF and SIO ontologies. A valid input is an instance of the bibo:Document class, with the text content attached via the bibo:content predicate and a MIME type of “text/plain” attached via the dc:format predicate. The resulting output attaches instances of SIO “chemical entity” to the input document URI via the foaf:topic predicate, where each “chemical entity” has attributes indicating the DrugBank [ ] identifier and any synonymous drug names. The semantics of foaf:topic are slightly stronger than is required in the context of the entity recognition task; however, since we failed to find a more suitable predicate, we followed a weaker interpretation where any object mentioned in the text was considered a topic of the document.
For the business logic of the entity recognition service, we implemented our own drug extraction algorithm based on a dictionary lookup. The dictionary was extracted from the DrugBank database and contains 58,708 entries, where each entry consists of the name of a drug, its DrugBank ID, and its canonical name in DrugBank. Drugs are recognized using the GATE ANNIE Gazetteer lookup tool , which loads the dictionary and annotates the text with DrugBank IDs and canonical names. At the final step, annotations of names with length less than 4 characters were filtered from results. The entity recognition service is a prototype and has not yet been evaluated in terms of precision and recall. Although it follows a basic lookup-based approach with naive filtering of candidates, it has shown qualitatively acceptable performance during testing of the Health Lens system.
The authors have provided a downloadable demonstration of the Health Lens system as a standalone executable jar file (). This jar file bundles all components of the prototype system, including the sample personal health profile, the SHARE query engine, the bookmarklet, and the SADI services for drug interactions and entity recognition. Please note that running the prototype requires a Java Runtime Environment (JRE) to be installed on your system.
To start the system the user must execute the jar file, which can be done on most systems by double-clicking the file. Alternatively, the user may run the jar by typing the following at a Linux/Windows/OSX command line prompt: java -Xmx1g -jar personal-health-lens.jar. Executing the jar file brings up a console that allows the user to start and stop the system on port 8080. (Please note that the current version of the system will only work correctly on port 8080.) Clicking "Start" starts up the local SADI services and the Joseki server that hosts the personal health database.
In most environments, the Start button will open the installation/testing page for the Health Lens bookmarklet in the user's default Web browser. If this does not happen automatically, the user must instead manually visit http://localhost:8080/ in a Web browser. The Health Lens bookmarklet can then be installed by dragging one of the two "Personal Health Lens" links near the top of the page onto the browser's bookmarks toolbar.
The webpage at http://localhost:8080/ can be used to test correct operation of the system. As the content of the test page is under the control of the authors, it provides a reliable means to separate issues with the system components from issues that are specific to the content of particular webpages. To run the bookmarklet against the test page, the user must click the Personal Health Lens bookmarklet in the toolbar, which will activate scanning of the page for dangerous substances. During scanning, an animated SADI logo appears in the top right hand corner of the page. When scanning is complete, the words "St. John's Wort" are colored in red and annotated with a stop sign symbol indicating a dangerous interaction. Clicking on "St. John's Wort" displays a dialog box with the details of the interaction between "St. John's Wort" and the personal health profile, as shown in. The warning indicates that St. John's Wort may decrease the efficacy of Alprazolam, a prescribed drug in the user's personal health profile. As evidence, it provides a link to a publication that describes the interaction, which is believed to due to the induction of the CYP3A4 enzyme.
Any webpage may be scanned for personally dangerous drugs by clicking the Health Lens bookmarklet. For example,shows the St. John's Wort warnings in the context of an online article regarding naturopathic treatments for depression [ ].
The Personal Health Lens is only one of many tools that have been developed in recent years to leverage personal health data. For example, profile-oriented smartphone applications are now available for identifying allergy-safe foods [, ], monitoring sleep patterns [ , ], and sharing medical information across physicians and caregivers [ , ]. The use of such personalized tools is likely to continue increasing as new forms of personal health data, such as genotyping and whole genome sequencing, become more readily available to the general public. What makes the Personal Health Lens architecture distinct from other personalization tools is that, in addition to the patient’s data and the set of analytical tools, there is a third component—the semantic model/query—which guides the selection of which tool to use given which set of data. Though in this prototype the semantic model was quite simplistic, taking the form of a SPARQL query relating to drug-drug interactions, the SHARE resolution engine is capable of interpreting significantly more complex models, for example, the clinician’s treatment trajectory for any given patient. As such, we believe this is the first personal health tool which has the potential for clinician-initiated personalized medical advice to be injected into the patient’s own health research browsing activities. Moreover, since the SADI Personal Health Lens has a flexible underlying infrastructure, we believe it can be easily adapted to operate in combination with many of these existing health-information-support tools to enhance the relevance, detail, or quality of their personalization.
The Personal Health Lens project was intended only as a prototype of a novel framework for patient/practitioner/Web interaction, and was not intended to be used by genuine patients. There are some important factors of the personal profile that are not yet taken into account when detecting relevant interactions, such as sex, age, drug dosages, and drug routes (eg, pills, creams, inhalers), to name a few. Beyond these issues, it is useful to point some general concerns with our approach to health browsing personalization, and possible solutions.
Unlike earlier efforts , the Health Lens makes no attempt to evaluate the quality of the information on any given page; “hazardous” pages containing overtly incorrect information are not automatically weeded-out, as they are in other portal-based approaches. If there were a public registry of evaluated webpages, this limitation could be partially overcome by adding that registry’s evaluation as part of the annotation pipeline; however, it could not be guaranteed that any page the reader had accessed would exist in that registry. Thus, by ensuring that our systems scales to the Web, we become limited in our ability to filter hazardous or fallacious information. Conversely, the Health Lens system, by not adopting a portal-like structure, becomes a more natural part of the patient’s Web exploration, and one that is under their control. Rather than appearing as a centralized “paternalistic” [ ] information source, the Personal Health Lens prototype allows the patient to choose when to bring the expert evaluation framework into their Web experience.
Although Health Lens does not attempt to evaluate the quality of information on webpages, information quality is still a relevant issue with respect to the underlying sources of drug interaction data. In this sense, much of the previous work and lessons learned from designing and maintaining portal-based sites such as MedlinePlus  could be usefully applied to Health Lens to build a more transparent and trustworthy system. For example, many metrics (“instruments”) have been developed for systematically evaluating information quality on webpages that might also be used to evaluate the quality of the drug interaction services. Existing information quality metrics are based on factors such as provision of article metadata (eg, authors, date of last update, supporting citations), accuracy of information, completeness of information, and balanced presentation of evidence [ ]; there also exist various composite scoring systems, such as DISCERN [ ], that employ weighted combinations of these factors. The criteria of completeness is particularly relevant to the drug interaction data sets, as there exists a potential danger that users will assume a substance is safe in the absence of any warnings about interactions. Building a perfectly comprehensive and up-to-date corpus of drug interaction data is obviously not a feasible goal, especially given the distributed nature of the system. This caveat must be made clear to the end users, and they must be reminded to consult a physician before making changes to their medication regimes, regardless of any warnings that the system does or does not report.
Another area where the system can potentially be improved is in catering to the user’s personal level of health literacy. While Health Lens makes no attempt to filter the webpages themselves by literacy level, the user’s literacy is still relevant for the appropriate presentation of warnings. Although we have intentionally described interactions in terms of high-level clinical effects (eg, “decreased efficacy of drug”), the supporting citations provided with the interactions are scientific publications and thus require a high level of medical knowledge to understand. In future work, providing references to trusted secondary sources such as MedLine Plus would probably be more appropriate for most users. As with the issues of information quality described above, our approach to accommodating the user’s literacy level could likely be informed by previous work. For instance, several ontology-based systems have been developed for automatically mapping expert medical terminology to equivalent consumer-friendly terminology (eg, [, ]), and these might be employed within Health Lens to generate more accessible warning messages. In addition, many sociological studies have employed metrics based on word complexity and sentence length (eg, the Fry Readability Formula) to gauge readability levels of health-related webpages in a systematic manner [ ]. These metrics might likewise be employed within the Health Lens framework to help present supporting documents for interaction warnings at an appropriate level of literacy.
Finally, it is important to note that there is a potential privacy concern relating to the use of a public drug interaction service—the system must send the URIs of the user's prescribed drugs out over the Internet in order to retrieve the relevant interactions. In general, there is a trade-off between the degree of privacy the user wants to maintain and the ability to utilize all possible sources of data for identifying conflicts. In future work, this issue can be addressed by allowing the user to indicate which types of data are safe to send over the Web. In addition, the user might also choose to restrict the system to services that support HTTPS. With respect to privacy, the prototype implementation errs on the side of caution by using a locally hosted drug interaction service.
We believe the SADI Personal Health Lens demonstrates that dynamically-generated, context-sensitive pipelines of data and analytical Semantic Web Services can be usefully applied to the personalization of health information on the Web. Moreover, this approach provides the unique ability to fine-tune these workflows through the utilization of expert knowledge within semantically-encoded guidelines. Thus, for the first time, the Personal Health Lens establishes a framework within which clinicians can provide on-demand guidance during their patient’s personal health explorations.
The development of Personal Health Lens and the underlying technologies of SADI and SHARE have been generously supported by CANARIE through their funding of the C-BRASS project. In addition, initial funding for the SADI and SHARE projects has been provided by the Heart and Stroke Foundation of BC and Yukon, Microsoft Research, and CIHR. Core funding for the Wilkinson laboratory has been provided by an award from NSERC, and Mark Wilkinson is funded by the Polytechnic University of Madrid and the Marie Curie COFUND programme.
Conflicts of Interest
Multimedia Appendix 1
A sample personal health profile for the Health Lens system.Notation3 File, 1KB
Multimedia Appendix 2
Sample input RDF for the SADI drug interaction service.Notation3 File, 610B
Multimedia Appendix 3
Sample output RDF for the SADI drug interaction service.Notation3 File, 3KB
Multimedia Appendix 4
The SPARQL query issued to the SHARE system, in order to precompute all known drug interactions with the personal health profile.SPARQL Protocol and RDF Query Language File, 277B
Multimedia Appendix 5
The SPARQL query issued by the bookmarklet, in order to obtain personally dangerous drugs from personal health database.SPARQL Protocol and RDF Query Language File, 2KB
Multimedia Appendix 6
Sample input RDF for the SADI entity recognition service.Notation3 File, 529B
Multimedia Appendix 7
Sample output RDF for the SADI entity recognition service.Notation3 File, 1KB
Multimedia Appendix 8
SADI Personal Health Lens Prototype Java ARchive File [Java ARchive File, 59MB ].
- WebMD. URL: http://www.webmd.com/ [accessed 2012-06-25] [WebCite Cache]
- White RW, Horvitz E. Cyberchondria. ACM Trans. Inf. Syst 2009 Nov 2009;27(4):1-37. [CrossRef]
- Burgess MS, Allam O, Gray WA, Al-Busaidi A. Patient-centred approach to focusing online health information search results. Proc. Int. 2006 Presented at: Int. Symposium on Electronic Personal Health Records 2006 (ISePHR06); 2006 Sep 28; Trondheim, Norway p. 5-16.
- Wood I, Vandervalk B, McCarthy L, Wilkinson M. OWL-DL domain-models as abstract workflows. Leveraging Applications of Formal Methods, Verification and Validation: Applications and Case Studies; 2012 Presented at: 5th International Symposium On Leveraging Applications of Formal Methods, Verification and Validation (ISoLA 2012); 2012 Oct 15-18; Heraklion, Crete p. 15-18. [CrossRef]
- Sinha PK, Sunder G, Bendale G, Mantri G, Dande A. Electronic Health Record: Standards, Coding Systems, Frameworks, and Infrastructures. Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons; 2012:-376.
- Luo G, Thomas SB, Tang C. Intelligent personal health record. In: Proceedings of the 1st ACM International Health Informatics Symposium. New York, NY: ACM; 2010 Presented at: 1st ACM International Health Informatics Symposium (IHI 2010); 2010 Nov 11-12; Arlington, VA, USA p. 326-335.
- Al-Busaidi A, Gray A, Fiddian N. Personalizing web information for patients: linking patient medical data with the web via a patient personal knowledge base. Health Informatics J 2006 Mar;12(1):27-39. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Klyne G, Carroll JJ. Resource Description Framework (RDF): concepts and abstract syntax URL: http://www.w3.org/TR/rdf-concepts/ [accessed 2012-06-25] [WebCite Cache]
- Hayes P. RDF semantics URL: http://www.w3.org/TR/rdf-mt/ [accessed 2012-06-25] [WebCite Cache]
- Motik B, Patel-Schneider PF, Parsia B, Bock C, Fokoue A, Haase P, et al. W3C Recommendation. OWL 2 Web Ontology Language: structural specification and functional-style syntax URL: http://www.w3.org/TR/owl2-syntax/ [accessed 2013-03-17] [WebCite Cache]
- Sirin E, Parsia B, Grau BC, Kalyanpur A, Katz Y. Pellet: a practical OWL-DL reasoner. Web Semantics: Science, Services and Agents on the World Wide Web 2007;5(2):51-53.
- Wilkinson MD, Vandervalk B, McCarthy L. The Semantic Automated Discovery and Integration (SADI) Web service design-pattern, API and reference implementation. J Biomed Semantics 2011;2(1):8 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Prud'hommeaux E, Seaborne A. SPARQL Query Language for RDF URL: http://www.w3.org/TR/rdf-sparql-query/ [accessed 2012-06-27] [WebCite Cache]
- Vandervalk B, McCarthy EL, Wilkinson MD. SHARE: A semantic Web query engine for bioinformatics. In: The Semantic Web. Shanghai, China: Proceedings of the Asian Semantic Web Conference (ASWC) 2009; 2009 Presented at: 4th Asian Semantic Web Conference (ASWC 2009); 2009 Dec 6-9; Shanghai, China p. 6-9. [CrossRef]
- The Semanticscience Integrated Ontology (SIO). URL: http://code.google.com/p/semanticscience/wiki/SIO [accessed 2012-06-25] [WebCite Cache]
- The Friend of a Friend (FOAF) Project. URL: http://www.foaf-project.org/ [accessed 2012-06-25] [WebCite Cache]
- Auer S, Bizer C, Kobilarov G, Lehmann J, Cyganiak R, Ives Z. Dbpedia: a nucleus for a Web of open data. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer; 2007 Nov Presented at: The Semantic Web; November 11-15, 2007; Busan, Korea p. 722-735.
- Wishart DS, Knox C, Guo AC, Shrivastava S, Hassanali M, Stothard P, et al. DrugBank: a comprehensive resource for in silico drug discovery and exploration. Nucleic Acids Res 2006 Jan 1;34(Database issue):D668-D672 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Tatonetti NP, Ye PP, Daneshjou R, Altman RB. Data-driven prediction of drug effects and interactions. Sci Transl Med 2012 Mar 14;4(125):125ra31 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Olvey EL, Clauschee S, Malone DC. Comparison of critical drug-drug interaction listings: the Department of Veterans Affairs medical system and standard reference compendia. Clin Pharmacol Ther 2010 Jan;87(1):48-51. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Boyce R, Collins C, Horn J, Kalet I. Computing with evidence Part II: An evidential approach to predicting metabolic drug-drug interactions. J Biomed Inform 2009 Dec;42(6):990-1003 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Wikipedia. Bookmarklet URL: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bookmarklet [accessed 2012-06-25] [WebCite Cache]
- Bibliographic Ontology Specification. URL: http://bibliontology.com/specification [accessed 2012-06-25] [WebCite Cache]
- DCMI Metadata Terms. URL: http://dublincore.org/documents/dcmi-terms/ [accessed 2012-06-25] [WebCite Cache]
- Cunningham H, Maynard D, Bontcheva K, Tablan V. GATE: A framework and graphical development environment for robust NLP tools and applications. Philadelphia, PA: Association for Computational Linguistics; 2002 Presented at: 40th Anniversary Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics (ACL'02); 2002 Jul; Philadelphia, PA.
- Naturopathic Treatment of Depression Symptoms. URL: http://www.livestrong.com/article/116731-naturopathic-treatment-depression-symptoms/ [accessed 2012-06-26] [WebCite Cache]
- MyFoodFacts. URL: http://www.myfoodfacts.com/ [accessed 2012-06-26] [WebCite Cache]
- Allergy guard. URL: http://www.covertapps.com/allergyguard [accessed 2012-06-26] [WebCite Cache]
- Sleep as Android. URL: https://sites.google.com/site/sleepasandroid/ [accessed 2012-06-26] [WebCite Cache]
- Sleep Cycle. URL: http://www.sleepcycle.com/ [accessed 2012-06-26] [WebCite Cache]
- iHEALTH LOG. URL: http://www.ihealthlogapp.com/Health_Log_iPhone_App/Overview.html [accessed 2012-06-26] [WebCite Cache]
- Express Well. URL: http://www.express-well.com/ [accessed 2012-06-26] [WebCite Cache]
- Miller N, Lacroix EM, Backus JE. MEDLINEplus: building and maintaining the National Library of Medicine's consumer health Web service. Bull Med Libr Assoc 2000 Jan;88(1):11-17 [FREE Full text] [Medline]
- Eysenbach G, Powell J, Kuss O, Sa ER. Empirical studies assessing the quality of health information for consumers on the world wide web: a systematic review. JAMA 2002;287(20):2691-2700. [Medline]
- Charnock D, Shepperd S, Needham G, Gann R. DISCERN: an instrument for judging the quality of written consumer health information on treatment choices. J Epidemiol Community Health 1999 Feb;53(2):105-111 [FREE Full text] [Medline]
- Smith B, Fellbaum C. Medical WordNet: a new methodology for the construction and validation of information resources for consumer health. In: Proceedings of the 20th International Conference on Computational Linguistics. Stroudsburg, PA: Association for Computational Linguistics; 2004 Presented at: 20th International Conference on Computational Linguistics (COLING '04); 2004; Geneva p. 23-27. [CrossRef]
- Bonacina S, Pinciroli F. An ontology-based tool for the correspondences between specialist and consumer medical lexicons for the geriatrics domain. Stud Health Technol Inform 2010;156:128-137. [Medline]
- SADI personal health lens prototype JAR. URL: https://cardioshare.googlecode.com/files/personal-health-lens.jar [WebCite Cache]
|BIBO: Bibliographic Ontotology|
|DC: Dublin Core|
|DDI: drug-drug interaction|
|FOAF: Friend of a Friend|
|JRE: Java Runtime Environment|
|OWL: Web Ontology Language|
|RDF: Resource Description Framework|
|SADI: Semantic Automated Discovery and Integration|
|SHARE: Semantic Health and Research Environment|
|SIO: Semanticscience Integrated Ontology|
|SPARQL: SPARQL Protocol and RDF Query Language|
|URI: Uniform Resource Identifier|
|UUID: Universally Unique Identifier|
|XML: Extensible Markup Language|
Edited by G Eysenbach; submitted 16.08.12; peer-reviewed by R Boyce, H Wu; comments to author 22.12.12; revised version received 01.02.13; accepted 03.03.13; published 05.04.13
©Ben Vandervalk, E Luke McCarthy, José Cruz-Toledo, Artjom Klein, Christopher J O Baker, Michel Dumontier, Mark D Wilkinson. Originally published in JMIR Research Protocols (http://www.researchprotocols.org), 05.04.2013.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work, first published in JMIR Research Protocols, is properly cited. The complete bibliographic information, a link to the original publication on http://www.researchprotocols.org, as well as this copyright and license information must be included.